Jonathan Miller and Dudley Moore
Uploaded by: auspete
Video Description:
Dr Jonathan Miller asks Dudley Moore to explain his piano playing abilities in mechanical terms. From Episode 11 of the BBC's "The Body In Question" (1978).
Tags for this video: bbc body dudley jonathan miller moore question
Find more videos in the "Entertainment" category
See more videos uploaded by auspete
Comments for this video: Show || Hide
| Comments for this video on YouTube |
| Perhaps also ... ( 7 months ago by MusicaBasket) |
| Perhaps also because he was both a classical and jazz pianist, which require different thought processes: improvisation v interpretation of another's composition. I'd love to have seen Jon and Dud get onto that. Too late now, sadly. |
| Oh come on auspete ... ( 5 months ago by Gaur1983) |
| Oh come on auspete have you read Aristophanes? Most of his jokes are totally modern and would not be out of place on an episode of South Park.Shakespeare on the other hand.... |
| It's actually a ... ( 5 months ago by auspete) |
| It's actually a white (or cream) background - which has been altered to a greenish tinge purely through PAL to NTSC conversion. The object at the top is a prostrate human body lying against a piece of white material. I'm not sure how they did it, or how better to describe it. The opening titles to each episode showed a sequence of human body movements from behind that same white material. It was an extraordinary concept which fitted in brilliantly with the tone and theme of the show itself. |
| Only Jonathan ... ( 5 months ago by auspete) |
| Only Jonathan Miller could get away with asking it, and only Dudley Moore could begin to provide a reasonable answer to it. |
| thanks for the ... ( 5 months ago by wildehewlett) |
| thanks for the reply auspete. does anyone else find Jon Miller HUGELY attractive? |
| Well worth the ... ( 5 months ago by johnclive021) |
| Well worth the listening, it's a natural gift that people like him have(had) and do develope, brilliant, thank you for posting. |
| I think Dudley sums ... ( 5 months ago by Gruntol5) |
| I think Dudley sums it up when he says "I don't know what I'm thinking of, actually." Marvellous! |
| I like the way even ... ( 5 months ago by clavdig) |
| I like the way even though he is having a serious discussion, he can still slip in the odd funny line 'im not up there that much' haha |
| I didn't know that ... ( 3 months ago by Mombuck) |
| I didn't know that Dudley was so accomplished on the piano. I remember a scene from Arther, but I thought he was just goofing. I'm glad there is a place where I can see the other work Dudley was known for:)Quite talented! |
| Any ideas on what ... ( 3 months ago by pcoldham) |
| Any ideas on what this piece of (Bach?) is called? Love this clip. The odd but effective way Jonathan Miller has of describing the 'keyboard inside your own spinal cord' and so forth reminds me of the kind of bizarre surrealism you get in old school science videos. There was a great parody called 'Look Around You' made recently which sums it up perfectly. |
| I once spent a ... ( 3 months ago by OofusTwillip) |
| I once spent a morning talking with Dudley, in Toronto, about 15 years ago. He said that he valued his musical abilities far more than his acting or comedy skills. In fact, he said that if he ever lost the ability to play the piano, it would be the end of everything. Tragically, he developed PSP (Progressive Supranuclear Palsy), which eventually robbed him of even basic motor skills. He first realized something was wrong when he could no longer control his pinky finger when he played the piano. |
| He's a kid from a ... ( 3 months ago by LiamE69) |
| He's a kid from a council estate that got a music scholarship to one of the best universities in the country. He really could play. |
| Reply to pcoldham ... ( 2 months ago by MICHKAC) |
| Reply to pcoldham The piece is the fantasia in C minor, BWV 906. |
| Separated at Birth: ... ( 2 months ago by solord) |
| Separated at Birth: Dr. Jonathan Miller & Tom Baker (Doctor Who). Interesting . . . |
| Does Dudley touch ... ( 2 months ago by jokingpants) |
| Does Dudley touch Jonathan Miller's genitalia at 6:49? |
| Nether regions, ... ( 2 months ago by auspete) |
| Nether regions, certainly! |
| What's the name of ... ( 2 months ago by demon27dan) |
| What's the name of the Mozart minuet Dudley plays at 2.30, and are there any other videos of this being played on YouTube? |
| these two are ... ( 2 months ago by 54spiritedwill54) |
| these two are amazing =] |
| It's minuet in C. ( 1 month ago by Niops) |
| It's minuet in C. |
| Not Minuet in C ( ... ( 1 month ago by hellpmaboab) |
| Not Minuet in C (which would be a slowish 3 in the bar) but Sonata. |
| LOL, that part is ... ( 1 month ago by dudleysjmoore) |
| LOL, that part is great. Part as in the segment, not Jonathan's part. ;-) |
| It's hard enough ... ( 1 month ago by dudleysjmoore) |
| It's hard enough thinking about it without having met him but I don't think I could have stood it hearing him say that and then having it happen that way. Too sad. |
| The challenge for ... ( 1 month ago by OofusTwillip) |
| The challenge for Dudley in this is trying to explain something that's always come as naturally to him as breathing. The same principle applies to teaching. The worst teachers are those trying to teach a subject that they'd learned almost instinctively. Imagine you were trying to teach an alien who had never breathed before, how to breathe. If you can't remember how you learned to do it, how can you teach the alien? |
| It might have been ... ( 1 week ago by pcouvela) |
| It might have been more illuminating (though less entertaining) for Dr Miller to catch a ball thrown to him and then describe his own mental processes, rather than ask about something completely foreign to him. He shows his lack of musical knowledge with the challenge of transposing the Mozart. Most classical players would be thrown, but not an accomplished jazz musician - especially one with as a refined a harmonic sense as Dud. |
Tell a friend:













